11. Besides, the licence agreement also contains an arbitration clause which should have been invoked first. 12. When Enron invoked the contract's arbitration clause , signs emerged that the government was open to renegotiations. 13. The " Tillman " court ultimately found the arbitration clause to be unconscionable and therefore unenforceable. 14. Typically, the validity of an arbitration clause is decided by a court rather than an arbitrator. 15. Baker says he never saw the arbitration clause . 16. C & L then sought to enforce the arbitration clause and the tribe claimed sovereign immunity. 17. The language of Kaiser Permanente's arbitration clause has withstood a challenge that eventually reached the California Supreme Court. 18. By a 5 4 margin the Court ruled for them, enforcing the arbitration clause in the plaintiffs'customer agreement. 19. In that case, the arbitration clause was contained in a contract between the shipyard and a classification society. 20. Years earlier, he had signed an arbitration clause as part of his registration with the New York Stock Exchange.