11. The Supreme Court reversed that ruling in 1999, saying the lower court wrongly decided the case without first holding a trial. 12. If a majority of the court disagrees with Plyler's reasoning, they might not see Plyler as just another wrongly decided case. 13. Justice Clarence Thomas, in a dissent joined by Justice Antonin Scalia, said flatly that Buckley was wrongly decided and should be overturned. 14. Last year, the Supreme Court reversed the 1998 ruling, saying the lower court wrongly decided the case without first holding a trial. 15. Mr . Toulson argued, if it was necessary to do so, that " Ross v Caunters " was wrongly decided . 16. I think Carnival Cruise was wrongly decided , but adherence to the holding in that case does not require the result the majority reaches today. 17. But Justice Clarence Thomas, in a dissent joined by Justice Antonin Scalia, said flatly that Buckley was wrongly decided and should be overturned. 18. Chemerinsky believes the case was " absolutely wrongly decided " but that he tries to be neutral in presenting the issues in class. 19. Ginsburg did not join that part of Stevens'dissent where he argued that " Buckley v . Valeo " was wrongly decided . 20. During confirmation hearings, Ashcroft told the Senate panel, " I believe Roe vs . Wade, as an original matter, was wrongly decided .
